| Year | Champion | Runner-Up | Third Place |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | Austin Legit | X-Mafia | One Hit Wonder |
| 2025 | X-Mafia | Smokin’ Bases | Balls Deep |
| 2024 | Austin Legit | X-Mafia | Smokin’ Bases |
| 2023 | Blue Sox | Austin | West Free Agent |
| 2022 | Austin Legit | Sandlot Boys | — |
| 2021 | Austin Legit | Smokin’ Bases | X-Mafia |
| 2020 | Not held (COVID) | ||
| 2019 | Austin Legit | X-Mafia | Mayhem/Miken |
| 2018 | Austin Athletics | Smokin’ Bases | Texas X-Mafia |
| 2017 | Smokin’ Bases | Austin Athletics | Houston Xtremes |
| 2016 | Austin Athletics | Men of Mayhem | Houston Xtremes |
| 2015 | Houston Xtremes | ATX | Texas Stampede |
| 2014 | Texas Stampede | Oklahoma Outlaws | El Paso |
| 2013 | ATX | Houston Punishers | Texas Stampede |
| 2012 | Rained out | ||
| 2011 | ATX | Southern Lightning | El Paso X-Force |
| 2010 | Austin Toons | Houston Xtremes | Southern Boyz |
| 2009 | Austin Toons | Houston Xtremes | Texas Desperados |
| 2008 | Austin Toons | Texas Desperados | Lafayette "A" |
| 2007 | Texas Toons | Texas Desperados | Okie: Boys/Summer |
| 2006 | Texas Toons | Dallas Blue Machine | Okie: Boys/Summer |
| 2005 | Texas Toons | Texas Desperados | Fort Worth Tornados |
| 2004 | Austin Toons | Jackson | Mississippi Coast |
| 2003 | Austin Toons | NACH Outlaws | Texas Diamondbacks |
| 2002 | Austin Toons | NACH Outlaws | Memphis |
| 2001 | Austin Reds | Metro Texas | Little Rock Silents |
| 2000 | Austin Angels | NACH Outlaws | San Antonio |
| 1999 | Austin Angels | Dallas Rangers | San Antonio |
| 1998 | Austin Angels | Jackson | Lafayette |
| 1997 | Austin Angels | NACH | Little Rock Silents |
| 1996 | Little Rock Silents | NACH | Memphis |
| 1995 | Jackson | NACH | San Antonio |
| 1994 | Austin Angels | Jackson | Lafayette |
| 1993 | Austin Angels | Dallas | Jackson |
| 1992 | Austin Angels | Baton Rouge | Houston Rebels |
| 1991 | Austin Angels | Houston Rebels | Fort Worth |
| 1990 | Austin Senators | Austin Angels | Fort Worth |
| 1989 | Austin Angels | Austin Senators | Memphis |
| 1988 | Houston Rebels | Austin Senators | Fort Worth |
| 1987 | Austin Senators | Houston Rebels | Dallas |
| 1986 | Dallas Blue Machine | Houston Rebels | Tulsa |
| 1985 | Houston Rebels | Austin Senators | Dallas |
| 1984 | Houston Rebels | Austin Senators | Irving |
| 1983 | Austin Senators | Dallas Blue Machine | Houston Rebels |
| 1982 | Dallas Blue Machine | San Antonio | Houston Rebels |
| 1981 | Dallas Blue Machine | Houston Rebels | New Orleans |
| 1980 | Houston Rebels | Dallas Blue Machine | Jackson |
| 1979 | Dallas Blue Machine | Austin Senators | Houston Rebels |
| 1978 | Houston Rebels | Dallas "A" | Austin Senators |
| 1977 | Capital City | Dallas "A" | Houston Silent |
| 1976 | Houston Rangers | Dallas "A" | Austin Senators |
| 1975 | Houston Rangers | Dallas "A" | San Antonio |
| 1974 | Houston Rangers | Austin Senators | San Antonio |
| 1973 | Austin Senators | Houston Rangers | Dallas |
| 1972 | Austin Senators | Baytown Rebels | Little Rock Silents |
| 1971 | Baytown Rebels | New Orleans Patriots | San Antonio |
| 1970 | Austin Senators | San Antonio | Houston Astros |
| 1969 | San Antonio | Dallas | Austin |
| 1968 | Houston Rangers | Louisiana Hippies | Dallas |
A dash means no team was recorded for that place. Spot a mistake? Email board@swsad.org.